• Guest Starring: Melanie Merkosky (Carla)
• Co-Starring: Amanda Spinosa (Rachel's Friend), Jasmine Miriguay (Rachel), Jovanna Burke (Bloody Mary), Sean Tyson (Clown Ghost), Isabella Barr (Carla's Daughter), Madison Barr (Carla's Daughter), Kyle Strauts (Cadaverous Ghost), Peter Skagen (Sheriff), Shanae Tomasevich (Woman in White)
• Written By: Andrew Dabb
• Directed By: John F. Showalter

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Emily Swallow (Amara), Ruth Connell (Rowena MacLeod), David Haydn-Jones (Arthur Ketch), Osric Chau (Kevin Tran), Lane Davies (Francis Tumblety), Melanie Merkosky (Carla)
• Co-Starring: Catherine Lough Haggquist (Jules), Justine Warrington (Society Woman Ghost), Michael Henderson (), Vladimir Ruzich (Scarred Ghost), Todd Thomson (Dave), Veenu Sandhu (Sheri), Alain Chanoine (Andy), Jenny Mitchell (Nan), Andrew Baker (Rob), Isabella Barr (Carla's Daughter), Paolo Maiolo (Hunter)
• Written By: Brad Buckner & Eugenie Ross-Leming
• Directed By: Robert Singer

• Guest Starring: Ruth Connell (Rowena MacLeod), David Haydn-Jones (Arthur Ketch)
• Co-Starring: Sharon Taylor (Ardat), Steven Allerick (Cal), Nevin Burkholder (Malfayan), Tori Katongo (Stevie), Donna Soares (Nurse)
• Written By: Robert Berens
• Directed By: Charles Beeson

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Emily Perkins (Becky Rosen), Ty Olsson (Benny Lafitte), Alison Araya (Vice Principal Bailey), Burkely Duffield (Billy Whitman), Andrew Airlie (Henry Whitman), Anne Marie DeLuise (Janet Whitman)
• Co-Starring: Mellany Barros (Veronica), Berkeley Ratzlaff (Tori Taylor), Jillian Knowles (Susie Martin), Jay Hindle (Rod), Jesse Franchuk (Bunker Demon)
• Written By: Davy Perez
• Directed By: Jensen Ackles

• Guest Starring: Anna Grace Barlow (Ashley Monroe), Luke Camilleri (Josh May)
• Co-Starring: Markian Tarasiuk (Andy May), Rachel Hayward (Sheriff Dignan), Ivy Matheson (Girl #3), Emma Cam (Julie), Andrew J. Hampton (Male Nurse)
• Written By: Steve Yockey
• Directed By: Richard Speight, Jr.

• Guest Starring: Shoshannah Stern (Eileen Leahy / Marlene), Jodelle Ferland (Emily), Keegan Connor Tracy (Mother Witch), Jennifer Spence (Melly Krokowski)
• Co-Starring: Art Kitching (Sheriff Alden Roy), Alex Sturman (Jacinda), Jasmine Lukuku (Receptionist), Sean Quan (Caleb Krokowski), Sebastian Kroon (Andy)
• Written By: Meredith Glynn
• Directed By: John F. Showalter

• Guest Starring: Shoshannah Stern (Eileen Leahy / Marlene), Dimitri Vantis (Sergei)
• And: Christian Kane (Lee Webb)
• Co-Starring: Aliyah O'Brien (Lorna), Emy Aneke (Sheriff J.C. Dillon), Madelyn Grace (Angela Sullivan), Georgia Bradner (Sally Anderson), Ryan Edward Elm (Bar Brawler), Brad Kelly (Bar Brawler)
• Written By: Jeremy Adams
• Directed By: Amyn Kaderali

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Shoshannah Stern (Eileen Leahy), Jake Abel (Adam Milligan), Keith Szarabajka (Professor Donatello Redfield), Anna Grace Barlow (Ashley Monroe), Ruth Connell (Rowena MacLeod)
• Co-Starring: Luvia Petersen (Sue Burrell), Kheon Clarke (Rowena's Demon), Lesha Vescio (Casino Bar Waitress), Sabrina Prada (Diner Waitress)
• Written By: Eugenie Ross-Leming & Brad Buckner
• Directed By: Richard Speight, Jr.

• Special Guest Star: Jim Beaver (Alternate Universe Bobby Singer)
• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Kim Rhodes (Sheriff Jody Mills), Shoshannah Stern (Eileen Leahy), Lisa Berry (Billie)
• Co-Starring: Tom Stevens (Leviathan)
• Written By: Robert Berens
• Directed By: Robert Singer

• Special Guest Star: DJ Qualls (Garth Fitzgerald IV)
• Guest Starring: Sarah Smyth (Bess Fitzgerald)
• Co-Starring: Danny Dworkis (Cutty), Emma Oliver (Gertie Fitzgerald), Austin Brody (Sam Fitzgerald), William Brody (Castiel Fitzgerald), Joe Allard (Announcer), Patrick Arnott (), Christian Lagasse (Teddy), Jesse Hutch (Brad), Daryl Ducharme (Maul), Jacob Machin (Store Clerk Ted)
• Written By: Andrew Dabb
• Directed By: John F. Showalter

• Guest Starring: Lynda Boyd (Moira / Fortuna), Hanneke Talbot (Evie)
• Co-Starring: Brent Stait (Joey Six), Stephen Huszar (Pax), Jason Burkart (Charlie), Ashley Roxburgh (Diner Waitress), Rob Bruner (Leonard), Ryan Hesp (Kabaiel), Lalo Espejo (Dr. Sariel), Kahlil Ashanti (Sheriff Jeb Evans)
• Teleplay By: Meredith Glynn
• Story By: Meredith Glynn & Davy Perez
• Directed By: Charles Beeson

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Kim Rhodes (Sheriff Jody Mills), Lisa Berry (Billie), Yadira Guevara-Prip (Kaia Nieves / Dark Kaia), Sandra Ferens (Merle)
• Co-Starring: Katherine Ramdeen (Alex Jones), Nicco Del Rio (Radio Shed Clerk), Amy Waugh (Radio Shed Customer)
• Teleplay By: Robert Berens
• Story By: Meredith Glynn & Robert Berens
• Directed By: Richard Speight, Jr.

• Guest Starring: Lisa Berry (Billie), Danneel Ackles (Sister Jo / Anael), Rachel Miner (Meg Masters)
• And: Genevieve Padalecki (Ruby)
• Co-Starring: Jesse Blue Franchuk (), William C. Vaughan (Demon), David H. Lyle (Man With a Broken Foot), Amélie Eve (Girl in the Garden)
• Written By: Brad Buckner & Eugenie Ross-Leming
• Directed By: Amyn Kaderali

• Guest Starring: Meagen Fay (Mrs. Butters), Kavan Smith (Cuthbert Sinclair)
• Co-Starring: Charlie Kerr (Vampire #1), Alden Doyle (Vampire #2), Skyler Mowatt (Thule Officer)
• Written By: Jeremy Adams
• Directed By: Eduardo Sánchez

• Guest Starring: Emily Swallow (Amara), Steve Bacic (Pastor Joe Robles), Nicole Munoz (Sylvia Robles)
• Co-Starring: Sara J. Southey (Valerie Jones), Meghan Drew (Patchwork Volunteer), Adam Beauchesne (Zack), Mark Dozlaw (Conner Todd), Thabo Ketshabetswe (Mitch), Beatrice Zeilinger (Sheriff Adams), Wonita Joy (Center Worker)
• Written By: Davy Perez
• Directed By: Matt Cohen

• Guest Starring: Lisa Berry (Billie), Christian Michael Cooper (Young Sam Winchester), Paxton Singleton (Young Dean Winchester), Elle McKinnon (Young Caitlin Johnson), Liam Hughes (Young Travis Johnson), Kelsey Crane (Caitlin Johnson), Ryan Alexander McDonald (Travis Johnson)
• Co-Starring: Bernadette Beck (Gwen), Cecilly Day (Sandy)
• Written By: Meghan Fitzmartin
• Directed By: Amyn Kaderali

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Emily Swallow (Amara), Rachel Miner (Meg Masters), Alessandro Juliani (Adam), Carmen Moore (Serafina)
• Co-Starring: Corina Bizim (Fangirl Angel), Christopher Webb (Male Angel), Eileen Barrett (Crystal / Talli), Duncan Bourke (Spa Attendant), Jeff Gladstone (Reaper)
• Written By: Meredith Glynn
• Directed By: Catriona McKenzie

• Special Guest Star: Jim Beaver (Alternate Universe Bobby Singer)
• Guest Starring: Lisa Berry (Billie), Briana Buckmaster (Sheriff Donna Hanscum), Rachel Miner (Meg Masters)
• And: Felicia Day (Alternate Universe Charlie Bradbury)
• Co-Starring: Catherine Lough Haggquist (Hunter), Max Boateng (Warding Reaper), Tori Katongo (Stevie), Jillian Walchuk (Lily and Dana's Mom), Sean Poague (Lily and Dana's Dad), Warren Abbott (Spencer), Paolo Maiolo (Hunter), Wolsey Brooks (Wounded Refugee Hunter), Josh Chambers (Chambers), Lillian Doucet-Roche (Hunter), Emma Pedersen (Hunter), Ava Grace Cooper (Lily), Kerensa Cooper (Dana)
• Written By: Robert Berens
• Directed By: Richard Speight, Jr.

• Guest Starring: Rob Benedict (Chuck Shurley / God), Jake Abel (Adam Milligan), Kimberley Sustad (Betty)
• Special Guest Star: Mark Pellegrino (Lucifer)
• Guest Starring: Kim Rhodes (Sheriff Jody Mills)
• And: Misha Collins (Castiel)
• Co-Starring: Meena Mann (Casey Ahuja)
• Written By: Eugenie Ross-Leming & Brad Buckner
• Directed By: John F. Showalter

• Special Guest Star: Jim Beaver (Bobby Singer)
• Co-Starring: Christine Chatelain (Jenny), Max Montesi (Vampire), Bentley Thomas Storteboom (Young Dean), Declan Locke (Teenage Dean), Greg Delmage (Father), Victoria Morgan (Mother), Beckham Skodje (Boy #2), Brady Droulis (Boy #1), Tina Grant (Akron Police Officer), Spencer Borgeson (Adult Dean)
• Written By: Andrew Dabb
• Directed By: Robert Singer