Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), John Rubinstein (Barry Colburn), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael B. Silver (Nathan Baxter), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Don Franklin (Randall Mathis), Bahar Soomekh (Margo), Julie Claire (Angela Rondello), Jonathan Banks (Shadow Man), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Chane't Johnson (Neesha), Kamal Marayati (Mr. Zeitoun), Clayton Rohner (Surfer Dude), Naz Deravian (Kadira Zeitoun), Joyce Guy (Judge), Lorena Mena (Jenga Player - Mom)
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Bahar Soomekh (Margo), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Josh Daugherty (Preisser)
Co-Starring: Thomas Wilson Brown (Grocery Store Deputy), John Antonini (Uniformed Cop)
Written By: Paul Zbyszewski
Directed By: Rob Bowman
Ep: 3
What if He Lets Her Go?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael B. Silver (Nathan Baxter), Bahar Soomekh (Margo), Peyton List (Ava), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Chane't Johnson (Neesha), Kamal Marayati (Mr. Zeitoun)
Co-Starring: Nick Hermz (Razi), Ben Bray (Train)
Written By: Steven Maeda
Directed By: Rob Bowman
Ep: 4
What if He Can Change the Day?
Guest Starring: Jonathan Banks (Shadow Man), Nestor Carbonell (Eddie Reyes), Don Franklin (Randall Mathis), Eric Steinberg (Slim), Peyton List (Ava), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Sonya Eddy (Waitress), Victor Togunde (Serious Man)
Co-Starring: Kwesi Boakye (James Mathis), Jeff Campbell (Police Officer), LaNiesha-Jopré Irvin (Whitney Mathis), Akie Kotabe (Honda Driver), Darryl Alan Reed (Angry Drunk), Van Earl Wright (TV Announcer)
Written By: Henry Alonso Myers
Directed By: Fred Keller
Ep: 5
What if They're Stuck?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Clifton Powell (Lieutenant Romero), Jonathan Banks (Shadow Man), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael B. Silver (Nathan Baxter), Brian Goodman (Lieutenant Darnell Graves), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Clayton Rohner (Surfer Dude), Josh Daugherty (Preisser), Shane Edelman (Roknowski)
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Jonathan Banks (Conrad Detweiler), John Getz (Unseen Man), Roxanne Hart (Margaret Detweiler), Anne Betancourt (Mrs. Contreras), Josh Daugherty (Preisser)
Co-Starring: Aldo Gonzalez (Carlos), Julieta Ortiz (Sister Magdalena), Cisco Reyes (Mico), Kevin Patrick Burke (Skinhead #1), Brian E. Oerly (Skinhead #2)
Written By: Charles Murray
Directed By: Rob Bowman
Ep: 7
What if He's Not Alone?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Clayton Rohner (Jared Pryor), John Rubinstein (Barry Colburn), Brent Jennings (Lloyd), Jeff Yagher (Forasz), Josh Daugherty (Preisser), Ward Horton (Concierge)
Co-Starring: Steven Barr (Hippo), Jesse Bernstein (MBA Guy), Dwier Brown (Scott Sommers), Marlene Forté (Mrs. Garza), Jeffrey Johnson (Driver), Cameron Meyer (Business Woman)
Written By: Jeffrey Bell & Steven Maeda
Directed By: Andy Wolk
Ep: 8
What if She's Lying?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Jenifer Lewis (Elizabeth Hopper), Don Franklin (Randall Mathis), John Getz (Tobias Booth), Jim Beaver ("Uncle" Nick Vukovic), Kris Iyer (Rao)
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), John Getz (Tobias Booth), Raymond Cruz (Luis Torres), Eric Steinberg (Slim), Marlene Forté (Mrs. Garza), Josh Daugherty (Preisser), Robert Neary (Balenger), Brian Keith Russell ()
Co-Starring: Scott DeFoe (Male Uniform #1), Wayne Mitchell (Male Uniform #2)
Written By: Angela Russo & John Hlavin
Directed By: Rob Bowman
Ep: 10
What if He's Free?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Luis Saguar (), Raymond Cruz (Luis Torres), Monique Gabriela Curnen (Alma Zapanta), Fredric Lane (Warden Nagel), Rochelle Aytes (Woman on Plane), Shane Edelman (), Michael Loeffelholz ()
Co-Starring: Kamal Marayati (Mr. Zeitoun), Bob Rusch (Prison Guard), Amy D. Higgins (Mrs. Patterson), Gary Price (Mr. Jarvick)
Written By: David Graziano & Charles Murray
Directed By: Elodie Keene
Ep: 11
What if He Walks Away?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Jim Beaver ("Uncle" Nick Vukovic), Sara Erikson (Hotel Desk Clerk Amy), Peter Allas (), Gizza Elizondo (Waitress), Jeanette O'Connor ()
Co-Starring: Josh Daugherty (Preisser), Steven Barr (Hippo), Matt Riedy (Father)
Written By: Jenny Lynn
Directed By: Bryan Spicer
Ep: 12
What if She's the Key?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Jonathan Banks (Conrad Detweiler), John Getz (Tobias Booth), John Rubinstein (Barry Colburn), Jim Beaver ("Uncle" Nick Vukovic), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Steven Barr (Hippo), Bahar Soomekh (Margo), Colin Kim (Billy), Michael Patrick McGill (Deputy)
Written By: Jeffrey Bell & Paul Zbyszewski
Directed By: David Von Ancken
Ep: 13
What if it's Him?
Guest Starring: Mitch Pileggi (Detective Spivak), Ian Anthony Dale (Detective Christopher Choi), Jonathan Banks (Conrad Detweiler), John Getz (Tobias Booth), John Rubinstein (Barry Colburn), Jim Beaver ("Uncle" Nick Vukovic), Michael McGrady (Buchalter), Joe Nieves (Fencik), Marlene Forté (Mrs. Garza), Tyrees Allen (Judge Nitzberg), Luis Saguar (), Bahar Soomekh (Margo)
