• Guest Starring: Morgan Taylor Campbell (Margot), Zachary Gordon (Jason "Blotter" Cohen), Charles Mesure (Sheriff Boyd Heelan), Tony Todd (Tall Man)
• Co-Starring: Jenna Berman (Krissy), Jan Bos (Mr. Lupus), Tommy Douglas (Posse Sheriff), Michelle Martin (Mrs. Tate), Kelly McCabe (Posse Deputy), Jaeda Lily Miller (Young Girl), Darren Moore (Dave), Marilyn Norry (Older Woman), Heba Shire (Mel), Rhys Williams (Jessie's Ex-Boyfriend)
• Written By: Edward Kitsis & Adam Horowitz & Ian Goldberg
• Directed By: Adam Horowitz

• Guest Starring: Zachary Gordon (Jason "Blotter" Cohen), Janet Kidder (Garrett's Mother), Charles Mesure (Sheriff Boyd Heelan), Tony Todd (Tall Man), Andrew J. West (Damon Crowley)
• Co-Starring: Ludmila Carmel (Katya Fayvinova), Donnie Cochrane (Metal Head Friend), Jesse Filkow (Gary), Allan Daniel Fisher (Anton Melnikov), Oleksandr Goldschmidt (Vladimir), Paul Herbert (Irate Customer), Clay Jadhav (Jeff), Sasha Piltsin (Mikhail Fayvinov), Rita Rajmova (Nadia), Anthony Shudra (Alexi Fayvinov), Benjamin Wilkinson (Tommy Delasotta)
• Written By: Ian Goldberg
• Directed By: Ron Underwood

• Guest Starring: Alex Fernandez (Hector Diaz), Charles Mesure (Sheriff Boyd Heelan), Lidia Porto (Mrs. Diaz), Andrew J. West (Damon Crowley)
• Co-Starring: Donnie Cochrane (Metal Head Friend), Lucie Guest (Erika), Harrison MacDonald (Travis), John C. MacDonald (Steve)
• Written By: Edward Kitsis & Adam Horowitz
• Directed By: Mick Garris

• Guest Starring: Molly Hagan (Beth), Andrew J. West (Damon Crowley)
• Co-Starring: Bobbi Charlton (Dr. Martin), Jaeda Lily Miller (7 Year-Old Andrea Dalton), Maeve O'Brien (13 Year-Old Andrea Dalton), Donnie Cochrane (Parker), Emily Delahunty (Girl Camper), Jesse Filkow (Gary)
• Written By: Edward Kitsis & Adam Horowitz
• Directed By: Tara Nicole Weyr

• Guest Starring: Tony Todd (Tall Man), Lovell Adams-Gray (Michael), Colin Lawrence (Joel's Dad), Taylor Russell (Laura)
• Co-Starring: Dante Arias (Younger Joel), Mark Dozlaw (Kenny), Allan Daniel Fisher (Anton Melnikov), Lia Franklin (Francie), Rhianna Jagpal (Thea)
• Written By: Erin Maher & Kay Reindl
• Directed By: Norman Buckley

• Guest Starring: Dylan Neal (Keith), Andrew J. West (Damon), Jesse Hutch (Fred Willingham), Janet Kidder (Garrett's Mother), Lidia Porto (Marta Diaz)
• Co-Starring: Donnie Cochrane (Parker), Eliza Faria (Ruby), RJ Fetherstonhaugh (Younger Keith Jones), Keisha Haines (Cindy), Tiera Skovbye (Younger Deb)
• Written By: Richard Hatem
• Directed By: Michael Schultz

• Guest Starring: Charles Mesure (Sheriff Heelan), Andrew J. West (Damon Crowley), Lovell Adams-Grey (Michael), Janet Kidder (Garrett's Mother), Colin Lawrence (Joel's Dad), Dan Payne (Jack Sykes), Anton Starkman (Younger Garrett Sykes)
• Co-Starring: Donnie Cochrane (Parker), Connor Stanhope (Lance), Shayla Wells (Young Jesse), Lucas Wyka (Young Damon)
• Written By: Ian Goldberg & Richard Hatem
• Directed By: Mairzee Almas

• Guest Starring: Sharon Leal (Renée), Tony Todd (The Tall Man), Andrew J. West (Damon Crowley)
• Co-Starring: Donnie Cochrane (Parker), Tommy Douglas (Posse Sheriff), Dominique Robinson (Carl), Chris Shields (Admission Rep), Jason Simpson (Masked Figure)
• Written By: Richard Naing & Steven Canals
• Directed By: Mick Garis

• Guest Starring: Dylan Neal (Keith Jones), Tony Todd (The Tall Man)
• Co-Starring: Jenna Berman (Krissy), Morgan Taylor Campbell (Margot Tate), Glenn Ennis (Marvin), Lia Frankland (Francie), Devielle Johnson (Policeman), Patrick Lubczyk (Kevin Hughes), Connor Mackay (Fireman), Chris McNally (Slick Guy), Darren Moore (Dave), Eliza Norbury (Amy's Mom), Marilyn Norry (Counselor), Shaughnessy Redden (Amy's Dad), Ava Sleeth (9 Year-Old Amy)
• Written By: Ian Goldberg
• Directed By: Alrick Riley

• Guest Starring: Zachary Gordon (Jason "Blotter" Cohen), Sharon Leal (Renée), Charles Mesure (Sheriff Boyd Heelan), Dan Payne (Jack Sykes)
• Co-Starring: Jenna Berman (Krissy), Ludmila Carmel (Katya Fayvinova), Allan Daniel Fisher (Anton Melnikov), Rhys Williams (Renée's Boyfriend), Nathan Witte (Young Deputy)
• Written By: Edward Kitsis & Adam Horowitz
• Directed By: Steve Miner