Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Derek Morgan (Roy Roebuck), Christopher Cousins (Tom Murphy), Jack Plotnick (Sammy #2), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Elaine Hendrix (Ms. Lischak), Louis Mustillo (Custodian / God), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), John Patrick Amedori (Loner Loser Kid / God), Cal Gibson (Groundskeeper / God), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Diane Delano (Coach Carol Keady), Cee Cee Michaela (Audra), Ransford Doherty (DeShawn Wallace), Cody McMains (Danny), Joe Sabatino (Construction Foreman), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters)
Co-Starring: Danny Musico (Simmons), Kent Faulcon (Duncan), Megan Swertlow (Peaches)
Written By: Joy Gregory
Directed By: Kevin Dowling
Ep: 27
The Cat
Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Derek Morgan (Roy Roebuck), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Allyce Beasley (Woman With Cats / God), Aaron Andrew Frazier (Basketball Player / God), Richard Penn (Dr. Hankin), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston), Cloris Leachman (Aunt Olive)
Co-Starring: Danny Musico (Simmons), Kent Faulcon (Duncan)
Written By: David Grae
Directed By: Steve Gomer
Ep: 28
The Election
Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Jared Hillman (Brian Beaumont), John Del Regno (Locksmith / God), Corri English (Elizabeth Goetzman), Megan Henning (Mari Darlene Fitch), Steele Justiss (), Morocco Omari (Principal Chadwick), Kristy Wu (Annie), Mike Erwin (Lars Klosterman), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Co-Starring: Sam Murphy (Donny), Mark Henderson (Craig Fitch), Julie Lancaster (Teri Fitch), Matt Spangler (Doug), Kyle Lupo (Teddy Marks), Michael J. Willet (Billy), Micah Williams (Freshman)
Written By: Ellie Herman
Directed By: Rob Morrow
Ep: 29
Wealth of Nations
Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Rick Overton (Bad Stand-Up Comedian / God), David Figlioli (Rudi Lake), Robert Pine (Mr. Baker), Kimberly McCullough (Beth Reinhart), Ian Bohen (Peter ), Iqbal Theba (East Indian Sunglasses Salesman / God), Trevor Einhorn (Mascot / God), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Co-Starring: Philip Marlatt (Roger), Vanessa Claire Smith (Surly Punk Girl)
Written By: Tom Garrigus
Directed By: Kevin Dowling
Ep: 30
P.O.V.
Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Patrick Fabian (Vice Principal Gavin Price), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Louis Mustillo (Garbage Man / God), Zachary Quinto (Pretentious Filmmaker / God), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Special Guest Star: Evan Handler (Chuck Kroner)
Co-Starring: Adrienne Evans (Elizabeth Rove), Max Knowles (7 Year Old Adam)
Co-Starring: Clement Von Franckenstein (Waiter at French Restaurant), Ansel Caine (Anarchist Guy), Charlie Koznick (Ryan), Scott Conte (Paramedic), Claudia Choi (Doctor), Karoly Gardello (Random Woman)
Written By: Stephen Nathan
Directed By: Elodie Keene
Ep: 32
No Future
Guest Starring: Riley Smith (Andy Baker), Patrick Fabian (Vice Principal Gavin Price), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Kimberly McCullough (Beth Reinhart), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Rae Allen (Fortune Teller / God), Kitty Swink (Annette Langston), Todd Sherry (Gay Male Secretary / God), Leslie Upson (Court Reporter / God), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Special Guest Star: Evan Handler (Chuck Kroner)
Co-Starring: Timothy NcNeil (Dr. Dan Padrovitch), Angela Robinson (Meter Maid), Stephen O'Mahoney (Cop)
Written By: Barbara Hall
Directed By: James Hayman
Ep: 33
The Book of Questions
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Christy Carlson Romano (Student / God), Jack Plotnick (Sammy #2), Kimberly McCullough (Beth Reinhart), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Paul Sand (Rabbi Polonsky), Mike Starr (Big Tough Guy / God), Joanne Baron (Female Guest / God), Mary Mara (Sarah Polonsky), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Kimberly McCullough (Beth Reinhart), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Jeffrey Licon (Goth Kid / God), Jack Plotnick (Sammy #2), John Marshall Jones (Chess Player / God), Mark Matkevich (Roger), Jane Daly (Janet Tuchman), René Ashton (Female Motivational Speaker / God), Yorgo Constantine (Vladimir Karpovich), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Special Guest Star: Kevin Rahm (Dana Tuchman)
Co-Starring: Jack Merrill (Uniformed Officer), Adrian Bloom (Waiter)
Written By: Tom Garrigus
Directed By: Gloria Muzio
Ep: 36
Queen of the Zombies
Guest Starring: Riley Smith (Andy Baker), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Mike Damus (Johnny Broadway / God), Sonya Eddy (Female Custodian / God), Todd Sherry (Gay Male Secretary / God), Corri English (Elizabeth Goetzman)
Co-Starring: Matthew Patrick Davis (Carl), Anne Abrams (Ms. Petrie), Brian Jones (Brad)
Written By: Joy Gregory
Directed By: Graeme Clifford
Ep: 37
The Rise and Fall of Joan Girardi
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Patrick Fabian (Vice Principal Gavin Price), Veanne Cox (Personable Woman / God), Jared Hillman (Brian Beaumont), Juliette Goglia (Little Girl / God), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Cheselka Leigh (Make-Up Lady / God), Lauren C. Mayhew (Elle ), Tyler Kain (Gabby), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Special Guest Star: Hilary Duff (Dylan Samuels)
Co-Starring: Gina St. John (Professional Reporter #2), Mark Hames (Professional Reporter #1), Ron Michaelson (Stage Manager), Micah Williams (Nerdy Kid), Kim Fifield (Indignant Girl), Keith Bogart (Storm Summers)
Written By: Lindsay Sturman
Directed By: Martha Mitchell
Ep: 38
Romancing the Joan
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Elaine Hendrix (Ms. Lischak), Mark Matkevich (Roger ), Juliette Goglia (Little Girl / God), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Michelle L. Gardner (Substitute Teacher / God), Gil Glasgow (Mr. Ward), Jordan David (Geek / God), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters), Annie Potts (Lieutenant Lucy Preston)
Special Guest Star: Haylie Duff (Stevie Marx)
Co-Starring: Rick Fitts (Paul Brumfield), Justin Scot (Officer Eicher), Susan Grace (Mrs. Gross)
Written By: Barbara Hall
Directed By: Joanna Kerns
Ep: 39
Independence Day
Guest Starring: Riley Smith (Andy Baker), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Kathryn Joosten (Old Lady / God), Jeffrey Licon (Goth Kid / God), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Kevin Chapman (Jim Lane), James Dumont (George Lane), Sven Holmberg (T-Shirt Vendor / God), Will.i.Am (Three Card Monte Guy / God)
Special Guest Star: Haylie Duff (Stevie Marx)
Written By: Ellie Herman & Stephen Nathan
Directed By: James Hayman
Ep: 40
Shadows and Light
Guest Starring: Nancy Lenehan (Erica Marx), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Sonya Eddy (Female Custodian / God), Edward Edwards (Charlie Marx), Vanessa Bell Calloway (Corey Phillips), Jack Kehler (Electrician / God), Al Mancini (Grandpa / God), Nikki Tyler-Flynn (Sweet Mother), Kate Norby (Dr. Jennifer Davis)
Special Guest Star: Haylie Duff (Stevie Marx)
Co-Starring: Sarah Lilly (Nora), Harry Hayman (Cub Scout / God)
Written By: Tom Garrigus & David Grae
Directed By: Kevin Dowling
Ep: 41
Secret Service
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Patrick Fabian (Vice Principal Gavin Price), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Elaine Hendrix (Ms. Lischak), Mike Starr (Big Tough Guy / God), Jeffrey Licon (Goth Kid / God), Larry Hankin (Homeless Man / God), Alexis Dziena (Bonnie), Rolando Molina (Trash Man / God), Aaron Paul (Denunzio), Austin Pendleton (Dietrich Steinholz), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters)
Teleplay By: Joy Gregory & Lindsay Sturman
Story By: Ben Eicher
Directed By: Michael Fresco
Ep: 42
Trial and Error
Guest Starring: David Burke (Father Mallory), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Kathryn Joosten (Old Lady / God), John Del Regno (Locksmith / God), Armin Shimerman (Ronald Harbison), Alexis Dziena (Bonnie), Adam Wylie (Skinny Kid / God), Kari Coleman (Natalie Hoyt), Joyce Guy (Judge Patricia Claymore), James Russo (James Karon), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters)
Co-Starring: Gina St. John (Reporter #2), Donna Ruthe (Reporter #1)
Teleplay By: Marc Flanagan
Story By: Matthew Donlan & Jeremy Martin
Directed By: Neal Israel
Ep: 43
Spring Cleaning
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Patrick Fabian (Vice Principal Gavin Price), David Burke (Father Mallory), Mike Starr (Big Tough Guy / God), Louis Mustillo (Garbage Man / God), Elaine Hendrix (Ms. Lischak), Mark L. Taylor (Salesman / God), Craig Welzbacher (Doyle), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters)
Special Guest Star: Kevin Rahm (Dana Tuchman)
Co-Starring: Christie Insley (Ginger), Courtney Hope (Chelsea)
Written By: Lyla Oliver
Directed By: Bethany Rooney
Ep: 44
Common Thread
Guest Starring: Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), Kathryn Joosten (Old Lady / God), Don McManus (Park Ranger / God), David Grammer (Carl Rove), David Marciano (Edmond Dodd), Shelly Cole (Punk Girl / God), Corinne Reilly (Anne Dodd), Wentworth Miller (Ryan Hunter)
Special Guest Star: Michael Badalucco (Father Payne)
Co-Starring: J. Marvin Campbell (Another Park Ranger), Payton Spencer (Kimberly Dodd)
Written By: Stephen Nathan
Directed By: Elodie Keene
Ep: 45
Something Wicked This Way Comes
Guest Starring: Sprague Grayden (Judith Montgomery), Aaron Himelstein (Friedman), David Burke (Father Mallory), Mageina Tovah (Glynis Figliola), Mark Totty (Detective Carlisle), Juliette Goglia (Little Girl / God), David Dorfman (Rocky Tardio), Jeffrey Licon (Goth Kid / God), Sonya Eddy (Female Custodian / God), Paul Sand (Rabbi Polonsky), Maria Costa (Police Officer), Wentworth Miller (Ryan Hunter), Constance Zimmer (Sister Lilly Watters)