Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (FBI Agent Park), Penn & Teller (Themselves), Erica Cerra (D.A. Jean Rosario), Bo Martynowska (Temperance Hudson), Rachel Colwell (Coffee Date)
Co-Starring: Geraldine Chiu (Jesse Fan), Ariah Lee (Ted Fan), Zoriah Wong (Charlie Fan), Angela Moore (Darlene Fowler), Ecstasia Sanders (Officer Joyce Marquez), Anthony Timpano (Dustin Yates), Will Jackson (Flynn), Sam Scherzer (Ryder), Paige Shaw (Bess' Date), Ana Mahmoodi (Forensics Tech)
Written By: Noga Landau & Melinda Hsu Taylor
Directed By: Amanda Row
Ep: 38
The Journey of the Dangerous Mind
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (FBI Agent Park), Bo Martynowska (Temperance Hudson), Stephen Lobo (Bertram Bobbsey), Giacomo Baessato (Connor)
Co-Starring: Geraldine Chiu (Jesse Fan), Ariah Lee (Ted Fan), Zoriah Wong (Charlie Fan), Ecstasia Sanders (Officer Joyce Marquez), Paul Piaskowski (Richard Trott), Anthony Timpano (Dustin Yates), Will Jackson (Flynn), Sam Scherzer (Ryder)
Written By: Celine Geiger & Andrea Thornton Bolden
Directed By: Amanda Row
Ep: 39
The Testimony of the Executed Man
Guest Starring: Rachel Colwell (Addy Soctomah), Bethany Brown (Laci McAllister)
Co-Starring: Ariah Lee (Ted Fan), Candus Churchill (Grandma McAllister), Paul Piaskowski (Richard Trott), David Epstein (Joe Kelsey), Jennifer Rose Garcia (Check-in Lady), Amanda Spinosa (Fan Fan), Aman Mann (Con-Goer), Chad Humeniuk (Darting Eyes), Arianna Bent (Woman in Veil), Ari Solomon (Night Watchman #2)
Written By: Jesse Stern
Directed By: Shannon Kohli
Ep: 40
The Demon of Piper Beach
Guest Starring: Osric Chau (Edwin George Chen), Erica Cerra (DA Jean Rosario), Ben Hollingsworth (Jake Cazine), Stephen Lobo (Bertram Bobbsey)
Co-Starring: Kathleen Duborg (Reverend Carter), Ecstasia Sanders (Officer Joyce Marquez), Paul Piaskowski (Richard Trott), Jesse Muhoozi (Kwame), Yasmeen Kelders (Talia), Max Archibald (Cameron), Ariel Ladret (CORA), Jenaya Ross (Sandman), Jordyn Bennett (Sandman - Little Girl)
Written By: Erika Harrison & Katherine DiSavino
Directed By: Clara Aranovich
Ep: 41
The Vision of the Birchwood Prisoner
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Anthony Natale (Captain Thom), Osric Chau (Edwin George Chen), Bo Martynowska (Temperance Hudson), Nicole Oliver (Rebecca)
Co-Starring: Paul Piaskowski (Richard Trott), Jason Tremblay (Kindly Dad), Warren Abbott (Officer Lehman), Austin Macwhirter (Asher Davies), Bentley Storteboom (Jonah), Benjamin Jacobson (Young Trott), Shelene Yung (HBPD Officer)
Written By: Melinda Hsu Taylor & Leilani Terrell
Directed By: Ruben Garcia
Ep: 42
The Myth of the Ensnared Hunter
Guest Starring: Anthony Natale (Captain Thom), Aadila Dosani (Amanda Bobbsey), Nicole Oliver (Rebecca), Carmen Moore (Hannah Gruen), Stephen Lobo (Bertram Bobbsey)
Co-Starring: Ecstasia Sanders (Officer Joyce Marquez), Richard Keats (Judge Abbott), Neemish Parekh (A.D.A. Marcus Francouer), Jesse Muhoozi (Kwame), Yasmeen Kelders (Talia), Max Archibald (Cameron)
Written By: Jen Vestuto & Melissa Marlette
Directed By: Larry Teng
Ep: 44
The Burning of the Sorrows
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Bo Martynowska (Temperance Hudson), Olivia Taylor Dudley (Charity Hudson Dow), Kayla Smith (Eve), Rachel Colwell (Addy Soctomah)
Co-Starring: Geraldine Chiu (Jesse Fan), Jesse Muhoozi (Kwame), Yasmeen Kelders (Talia), Max Archibald (Cameron), Ariel Ladret (Cora Dow), Kenny Wood-Schatz (Beckett Dow), Matthew Sears (Specter of Charity's Father), Chloe McKinnon (Specter of Young Charity)
Written By: Katie Schwartz
Directed By: Larry Teng
Ep: 45
The Voices in the Frost
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Olivia Taylor Dudley (Charity Hudson Dow), Carmen Moore (Hannah Gruen), Kayla Smith (Eve)
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Olivia Taylor Dudley (Temperance Hudson), Erica Cerra (D.A. Jean Rosario), Carmen Moore (Hannah Gruen), Rachel Colwell (Addy Soctomah), Giacomo Baessato (Connor), Andres Joseph (Tyler Gillis)
Guest Starring: Olivia Taylor Dudley (Temperance Hudson), Erica Cerra (D.A. Jean Rosario), Dejan Loyola (Lev J. Stern), Katherine Evans (Daniela Pino)
Co-Starring: Angela Moore (Darlene Fowler), Richard Keats (Judge Abbott), Sean Depner (Peter Tombar), Jenaya Ross (Copperhead), Denzel Brooks (Felix Raybolt), Melania Solano (Kiran), Micah Steinke (Randall), Jesse Kelly-Brandes (Officer), Jason Reid (Sheriff Deputy), Elizabeth McCarthy (Juror #1), Jasmine Lukuku (Juror #2), Keon Lyn (Juror #4), Danny Dworkis (Juror #7), Deborah Scott (Ms. MacCorkle)
Written By: Céline Geiger
Directed By: Larry Teng
Ep: 48
The Witch Tree Symbol
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Olivia Taylor Dudley (Temperance Hudson), Dejan Loyola (Lev J. Stern), Marilyn Norry (Myrtle Hudson)
Co-Starring: Angela Moore (Darlene Fowler), Geraldine Chiu (Jesse Fan), Ariah Lee (Ted Fan), Zoriah Wong (Charlie Fan), Jesse Muhoozi (Kwame), Yasmeen Kelders (Talia), Max Archibald (Cameron), Jenaya Ross (Copperhead), Dominic Good (Tommy), Bella Grace (Tina), Kenny Wood-Schatz (Beckett Dow), Madeleine Kelders (Fora)
Written By: Erika Harrison
Directed By: Larry Teng
Ep: 49
The Ransom of the Forsaken Soul
Guest Starring: John Harlan Kim (Agent Nelson Park), Olivia Taylor Dudley (Temperance Hudson), Rachel Colwell (Addy Soctomah), Sharon Taylor (Shelby Glass), Thomas Cadrot (Jonas Glass)
Co-Starring: Geraldine Chiu (Jesse Fan), Ariah Lee (Ted Fan), Zoriah Wong (Charlie Fan), Ecstasia Sanders (Officer Joyce), Richard Keats (Judge Abbott), Trevor Lerner (Fred), Ellie Harvie (Lily), Sean Depner (Peter Tombar), Melania Solano (Kiran), Curranne Labercane (Copperhead), Adam Pateman (Contractor)