Co-Starring: Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Marti Matulis (Horseman of War), Luke Smith (Moloch - Riding)
Written By: Mark Goffman
Directed By: Ken Olin
Ep: 15
The Kindred
Guest Starring: Sakina Jaffrey (Sheriff Leena Reyes), Timothy Busfield (Benjamin Franklin), Patrick Gorman (Reverend Knapp), Derek Mears (Moloch)
With: Neil Jackson (Abraham Van Brunt)
Co-Starring: Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman - Weapons), Craig Branham (Headless Horseman - Riding), Eric Mainade (War - Weapons), Ed Dabney (War - Riding), Luke Smith (Kindred - Riding), Matt Mercurio (Deputy), Michael Rosander (Bank Salesman), Jared Simon (Polygraph Examiner), Christopher Eaddy (Orderly #1), Benjamin Rowe (Orderly #2)
Written By: Mark Goffman & Albert Kim
Directed By: Paul Edwards
Ep: 16
Root of All Evil
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Sakina Jaffrey (Sheriff Leena Reyes)
With: Neil Jackson (Abraham Van Brunt)
Co-Starring: Surely Alvelo (Terrytown Psych Nurse), Stephen Ayers (Shopkeeper), Shaun Clay (Booking Sheriff), Scott Depoy (Priest), Kimberley Drummond (Sofie), Marc Farley (Gerry), Sean Goulding (Dave), Megan Hayes (Dana Dobbs), Joy Jacobson (Ms. Galway), Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Scott Poythress (Benedict Arnold)
Written By: Melissa Blake & Donald Todd
Directed By: Jeffrey Hunt
Ep: 17
Go Where I Send Thee...
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Francie Swift (Beth Lancaster)
Co-Starring: Ryan Gray (Pied Piper), Abigail Cornell (Sara Lancaster), John Colton (Daniel Lancaster), Tom Hillmann (Richard Weiss), Alan Wells (Intermediary), Morgan Hinkleman (Lancaster Daughter at 10 Years), Heather Gilliland (Lancaster Daughter #1), Katelyn Farrugia (Lancaster Daughter #2), Erika Edwards (Lancaster Daughter #3), Ryan Boz (Lancaster-Weiss Brother #1), Christian Scales (Lancaster-Weiss Brother #2), Sterling Santiago Baron (Lancaster-Weiss Brother #3)
Written By: Damian Kindler
Directed By: Doug Aarniokoski
Ep: 18
The Weeping Lady
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Heather Lind (Mary Wells), Derek Mears (Moloch), Laura Spencer (Caroline)
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Zach Appelman (Joe Corbin), Eddie Spears (Big Ash)
And: Clancy Brown (Sheriff August Corbin)
Co-Starring: Robin Strasds (Daniel Boone), Arthur Bridgers (David), Michael Harding (Gil Everett), Marti Matulis (Wendigo), Dane Davenport (Rob), Scott Parks (Hessian #1), Devin McGee (Hessian #2), Kevin Patrick Murphy (Bartender)
Written By: Heather V. Regnier
Directed By: Doug Aarniokoski
Ep: 20
Deliverance
Guest Starring: Sakina Jaffrey (Sheriff Leena Reyes), Derek Mears (Moloch), Adam Sinclair (Hellfire Doctor)
With: Neil Jackson (Abraham Van Brunt)
Co-Starring: Darla Delgado (Dr. Lim), Nick Madrick (Unit Leader), Matt Mercurio (Deputy), Suellen Yates (Elderly Woman), Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Braden Fitzgerald (Young Jeremy Crane)
Written By: Sam Chalsen & Nelson Greaves
Directed By: Nick Copus
Ep: 21
Heartless
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Caroline Ford (Lilith)
With: Neil Jackson (Abraham Van Brunt)
Co-Starring: Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Elena Sanchez (Lilith Demon), Greg Perrow (Duncan), Connor McCabe (Robbie), Raven Angeline Whisnant (Kalinda), Colin Owens (Eric), Jenna Bryant (Melissa), Mary Russell (Becky), Brett Kelley (Bachelor), Sophia Grillo (Bachelorette), Kevin Patrick Murphy (Bartender)
Written By: Albert Kim
Directed By: David Boyd
Ep: 22
Mama
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Sakina Jaffrey (Sheriff Leena Reyes)
With: Cynthia Stevenson (Gina Lambert)
And: Aunjanue Ellis (Lori Mills)
Co-Starring: Myke Holmes (Walt), Joshua C. Allen (Nelson), Grant Springate (Boy Moloch), Haley Walker (Young Abbie), Melannie Sanchez (Young Jenny)
Co-Starring: Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Marti Matulis (Moloch), Ed Dabney (War - Riding), Dane Rhodes (Jeff)
Written By: Mark Goffman
Directed By: Dwight Little
Ep: 25
Paradise Lost
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Max Brown (Orion)
With: Neil Jackson (Abraham Van Brunt)
Co-Starring: Josh Carter (Bartender), Tyler Chase (Teenage Clerk), Allie McCulloch (Farmer), Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman)
Written By: M. Raven Metzner
Directed By: Russell Fine
Ep: 26
Pittura Infamante
Guest Starring: Sakina Jaffrey (Sheriff Reyes), Patrick Gorman (Reverend Knapp), Jill Marie Jones (Cynthia Irving), Aaron Serotsky (Grant Hollister)
And: Michelle Trachtenberg (Abigail Adams)
Co-Starring: Gregory Nassif St. John (Evan Miller), Daniel Thomas May (James Colby), Parisa Johnston (Docent), Victor Cordova (Officer #1), Shaun Clay (Officer #2), Elise DuQuette (Server)
Written By: Melissa Blake
Directed By: John Leonetti
Ep: 27
Kali Yuga
Guest Starring: Matt Barr (Nick Hawley), Jaime Murray (Carmilla Pines), Jill Marie Jones (Cynthia Irving)
Co-Starring: Ashley LeConte Campbell (Judge Aldrin), Randy Havens (McKenna), Ron Rogge (Henry Knox / Theodore Knox), Heather V. Regnier (Karaoke Announcer), Whit Davies (D.A.)
Teleplay By: Sam Chalsen & Nelson Greaves
Story By: Heather V. Regnier
Directed By: Doug Aarniokoski
Ep: 28
Spellcaster
Guest Starring: Johnathon Schaech (Solomon Kent)
Co-Starring: Genevieve Barker (Newscaster), Nolan Bateman (Ronnie Rawlings), Jesse C. Boyd (Aaron), Lindsey Garrett (Sarah Osborne), Belinda Keller (Churchgoer), Antwan Mills (Guard), Andrea Powell (Mary Rawlings), Tia Robinson (Keely), Jason Stuart (Curator), Adrienne Whitney (Assistant)
Written By: Albert Kim
Directed By: Paul Edwards
Ep: 29
What Lies Beneath
Guest Starring: Sharif Atkins (Calvin Riggs)
And: Steven Weber (Thomas Jefferson)
Co-Starring: Chris Greene (Daniel Riggs), Fernando Martinez (Burke), Jeremy Palko (McGrady), Richard Fullerton (Veteran), Jessica Goei (Young Teen #1), Alyssa Claytor (Young Teen #2)
Teleplay By: Damian Kindler
Story By: Damian Kindler & Phillip Iscove
Directed By: Dwight Little
Ep: 30
Awakening
Co-Starring: Adam Boyer (Bowie), Al-Jaleel Knox (Clerk), Shelby Steel (Stella), Raven Rainwater (Charles), Deborah Ayorinde (Michelle), Annie Humphrey (Cori), Regina McKenzie (Widow), Jonathan D. Williams (Rob), Shane Callahan (Wagon Guard), Rob Maniscalco (Accountant), Jaret Sears (Soldier #1), Jeff Sandor (Soldier #2), Ed Wagenseller (Wagon Driver)
Written By: M. Raven Metzner
Directed By: Doug Aarniokoski
Ep: 31
Tempus Fugit
Guest Starring: Timothy Busfield (Benjamin Franklin), Marc Menchaca (Colonel Sutton)
Co-Starring: Onira Tarés (Grace Dixon), Jeremy Owens (Headless Horseman), Craig Branham (Headless Horseman - Riding), Karen Boles (Nurse), Alan Heckner (Jailer), Matthew Dearman (Soldier), RJ Shearer (Private McMillan)
